Student Painters in Ottawa vs a Full-Time Crew
Which jobs a student crew handles well, which need more experience, and how to compare two quotes line by line.
By Daniel Mercer, owner
Student painters in Ottawa are a reasonable choice for simple jobs, and a weaker fit for failing wood siding, cabinets and heavy repairs. Paint Experts is a full-time crew whose painters have 6 to 18 years in the trade. On the same exterior, our quote usually lands 10 to 25 percent above a lower-priced student crew.
| Student crew | Paint Experts | |
|---|---|---|
| Good fit | Bedrooms, basic interior repaints, fences, sheds, uncomplicated exteriors | The same, plus older wood siding, heritage trim, cabinets, extensive repairs |
| Example exterior quote | $5,000 | $5,500 to $6,250 |
| Season | Mostly summer | Year-round |
| Experience | Varies with training and supervision | 6 to 18 years per painter, about 11 on average |
| Warranty | Compare the written terms | Two years on workmanship, in writing |
Jobs a student crew handles well
A properly trained and supervised student crew is a good option for simple painting: bedrooms, basic interior repaints, fences, sheds and uncomplicated exterior surfaces.
We have seen excellent work from student crews, and poor work from experienced contractors. Age is not the issue. Training, supervision, preparation and quality control are.
Jobs where experience changes the result
We would be more selective for:
- Older wood siding with failing paint
- Intricate heritage trim
- Difficult access
- Kitchen cabinets
- Extensive repairs
- Anything involving potentially hazardous materials, such as lead paint or asbestos
The question to ask any crew is whether it has the skills and equipment for that particular job.
The price difference on one exterior
If a student painting company quotes $5,000 for an exterior, our quote for the same house might be $5,500 to $6,250.
That is not a rule. Some established student-painting franchises charge about the same as professional contractors. It depends on the two bids in front of you.
Questions about your project? Talk to us directly.
(613) 801-7316What to compare line by line in two quotes
Do not compare totals alone. Compare what is included:
- Written preparation steps: washing, scraping, sanding, priming
- The paint line and number of coats
- Insurance and WSIB coverage
- Who inspects the work and when
- The warranty, in writing
Our quotes spell out each of these.
What we are asked to fix after a rushed job
Occasionally we are called in after a student crew. The usual list: uneven coverage, missed preparation, rough cut lines, paint drips, peeling exterior paint and poorly repaired cracks.
Exterior problems show up fastest, because Ottawa weather finds weak preparation quickly.
Summer crews and year-round crews
Our painters are full-time tradespeople who work through the year, not only in the summer exterior season. The lead painters have more than ten years each, and the same lead stays on a job from start to finish.
Choosing between a student crew and a professional crew
Are student painters cheaper?
Often, by 10 to 25 percent on a lower-priced bid. Some student franchises charge about the same as professional contractors.
Are student painters any good?
Many are, on simple jobs with good training and supervision. Ask who supervises and what preparation is included.
What jobs should not go to a student crew?
We would be selective with failing wood siding, heritage trim, cabinets, extensive repairs and anything with lead paint or asbestos risk.
What should a painting quote include?
Preparation steps, the paint line, number of coats, insurance, inspections and a written warranty.
Do you paint in winter?
Interiors, yes, all year. Exteriors run from late April or early May into October.
Compare your quote with ours
Already have a quote from another crew? Send it with a few photos of the house. We will quote the same scope in writing so you can compare line by line.